Sarah's Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing Sarah's Pizza, a delightful pizza haven located at 77 E Dayton St, West Alexandria, OH. Known for its quality and vibrant menu, Sarah’s offers an array of delicious options that cater to all palates. From classic favorites like pepperoni to unique specialty pies such as the mashed potato pizza and bacon double cheeseburger pizza, there's something for everyone.

The restaurant prides itself on its quick service, whether you choose to dine in or opt for delivery. Merging nostalgic comfort food with modern convenience, it features family-friendly dining, outdoor seating, and also accommodates wheelchair access. With efficient takeout services and a notable catering option for larger gatherings, Sarah's aims to provide a welcoming experience for all.

Join the locals who rave about their generous toppings and enjoy great deals during happy hours. A true gem for pizza lovers, Sarah's Pizza promises tasty bites in a friendly, community-focused atmosphere.

Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$$3.00

One Topping Pizza

$$3.50

Two Topping Pizza

$$4.00

Three Topping Pizza

$$4.50

Four Topping Pizza

$$5.00

Breadsticks

With cheese, pizza sauce or garlic butter.

$$1.99

Cinnamon Sticks

With icing.

$$1.99

Family Breadsticks

$$4.49

Pizza Bread

One topping.

$$2.75

Seasoned Fries

$$1.99

Regular Fries

$$1.99

Nacho Chips

With cheese sauce.

$$1.99

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks

$$3.99

Jalapeno Poppers

$$3.99

Mini Corn Dogs

$$1.99

Specialty Items

Pasta

Baked Spaghetti

With meatballs and garlic bread.

$$6.00

Baked Lasagna

With garlic bread.

$$6.00